Mexican Chocolate Cream Pie

For the finale of the marathon, I thought of making molten lava chocolate. It has been on my to-bake list for a long time and that was the first recipe I listed down when I decided on chocolate theme for this marathon. 3-4 days ago I went to Whole Foods to pick up some pizza dough and when standing in the checkout line, I saw a Cooking Light special edition magazine. I browsed through the magazine and Mexican Chocolate Cream Pie caught my eye and moreover, it would go with my theme. I bought the magazine, showed it to Mr.U yesterday and asked him if he likes any of the recipes from the magazine, not necessarily desserts. I would make it. He wanted me to make Mexican Chocolate Cream Pie. I was in no mood to make it yesterday and more over, I am a little intimidated making custard/pudding with eggs. I have made it in the past, but I am always afraid I might mess it up.

This morning I was leaning towards molten lava cake and U asked if I was making the pie today. And here I am, with the Mexican Chocolate Cream Pie. I followed the recipe as given with a few substitutions as I did not have those ingredients in my kitchen. I substituted espresso powder with instant coffee, frozen cool whip whipped topping with reddi whip and I skipped chili powder as it is an optional ingredient.

The pie turned about good but I would make a few changes the next time. Pie crust called for cinnamon powder and I did not really care for it. I might cut back a little on it or skip it all together. U liked the cinnamon flavor though. I also found the pie crust little crispy and very firm. I would reduce the baking time for the crust, the next time I bake it, I wanted to get cool whip whipped topping but U wanted to tasty the pie right away, so I used Reddi whip. I would recommend using Cool Whip instead. Also, do not be intimated by the lengthy ingredient list. It is a very easy preparation. Make & bake the pie crust, prepare the custard, fill it in the pie and refrigerate until set. That’s it!

Mexican Chocolate Pie, Cooking Light, Chocolate Mela, Blogging Marathon, Chocolate Pie

Source: The Best of Cooking Light 13 Special Edition
Total Time: 35 minutes
Preparation: 10 minutes
Cooking Time: 10 – 15 minutes
Baking Time: 7 – 9 minutes
Refrigerating Time: 3 hours
Serves: 8


  • 1 ½ cups Graham Cracker Crumbs or 10 Crackers (can use any digestive biscuits)
  • 2 tbsp. Sugar
  • 1 tsp. Cinnamon Powder
  • 1/8 tsp. Salt
  • 2 tbsp. Egg Whites (1 egg white)
  • 2 tbsp. melted Butter


  • ½ cup Sugar
  • 2 tbsp. Corn Starch
  • 1 tbsp. Unsweetened Cocoa Powder
  • ¼ tsp. Instant Espresso Powder (I used Bru Instant Coffee Powder)
  • 1/8 tsp. Salt
  • 1/8 tsp. ground Red Pepper (I did not use it)
  • 1 Large Egg
  • 1 Large Egg Yolk
  • 1 ¾ cups 2% reduced fat Milk (I used 1% Milk)
  • 2 oz. Dark Chocolate chopped (I used 1 oz. bitter chocolate and 1 oz. milk chocolate. Recommend dark chocolate)
  • 1 ½ cups frozen reduce-calorie whipped topping (I recommend Cool Whip)


  • Pre-heat the oven to 375 F.
  • Break graham crackers into small pieces and run it in the food processor for few seconds. It does not have to be a fine powder.
  • Keep aside 1 tbsp. for topping and take the rest into a bowl.
  • Add cinnamon, sugar, salt to the crumbs and mix well.
  • Add egg white and butter to the mixture and mix well.
  • Grease a 9” pie pan with cooking spray. I lined the pie dish with an aluminum foil & then sprayed the cooking oil.
  • Transfer the mixture to the pie pan, press it to the pan.
    Mexican Chocolate Pie, Cooking Light, Chocolate Mela, Blogging Marathon, Chocolate Pie

  • Bake it for 9 minutes or until the crust is lightly toasted. I would recommend baking for less than 9 minutes as mine was very firm.
  • Remove from oven and cool it on a wire rack until completely cool.
    Mexican Chocolate Pie, Cooking Light, Chocolate Mela, Blogging Marathon, Chocolate Pie


  • Combine sugar, corn starch, cocoa powder, espresso powder, salt, whole egg & a yolk and whisk well.
    Heat milk in a heavy bottom pan on medium high heat until it just begins to boil and tiny bubbles form around the corners.
  • Turn off the heat (it is not required but I did), gradually add some hot milk to the egg mixture, whisking constantly.
  • Transfer the milk egg mixture back to hot milk and cook it on medium heat, whisking it constantly.
  • The recipe called for cooking it for 10 minutes until thick and bubbly. I cooked it for 7 minutes.
    Mexican Chocolate Pie, Cooking Light, Chocolate Mela, Blogging Marathon, Chocolate Pie

  • Remove from heat, add chopped chocolate and stir/whisk it until chocolate is melted.
  • Transferred the filling into a bowl and cooled it in an ice bath. One can put the pan directly in a bowl of ice.
    Mexican Chocolate Pie, Cooking Light, Chocolate Mela, Blogging Marathon, Chocolate Pie

  • Pie

  • When completely cool, pour the filling into the crust, cover it with a saran wrap and refrigerate until the pie is set.
    Mexican Chocolate Pie, Cooking Light, Chocolate Mela, Blogging Marathon, Chocolate Pie

  • Spread whipped topping on top of the chocolate filling, sprinkle with the cracker crumbs, refrigerate until ready to serve.

Mexican Chocolate Pie, Cooking Light, Chocolate Mela, Blogging Marathon, Chocolate Pie


  • I would skip cinnamon powder or add very little.
  • I would reduce the baking time for the pie.
  • Use Cool Whip frozen whipped topping instead of Reddi Whip cream.

Egg less Pie

  • Egg white can be omitted in the preparation of pie crust and if required add more butter. I think additional butter is not required.
  • For the filling, egg can be skipped. I have not tried it but this filling recipe is similar to chocolate custard I made few days ago. I am guessing this filling would taste fine even without eggs.OR can add little gelatin or agar agar.
  • For semi-homemade chocolate cream pie, get a store bought pie crust, for the filling use Jell-O instant chocolate flavored pudding.

Recipes posted this day: in 2010 Ragi Java and in 2011 Ground Chicken Vegetable Pulao
Recipes posted this month: in 2009, in 2010 & in 2011.
Blogging Marathon: To know more about the various themes and participating bloggers for this marathon, checkout the blogging marathon page on Srivalli’s blog.
Event Entries: Sending these brownies to Srivalli’s Chocolate Mela, Pradnya’s Bake Fest # 3, an event started by Vardhini, Srav’s Cooking Concepts # 6: Chocolate Fest and Ramya’s ABC Series: Desserts.

Chocolate Mela

23 Responses to Mexican Chocolate Cream Pie

  1. looks very good..I was planning to bake an eggless pie but somehow didn’t have the right ingredients :) It has been nice to run the Marathon with you, Usha.

  2. the pie could go eggless…but what about the choc stuffing…cud something be worked out…?may b …let me rack my brain…though this looks gorgeous Usha…

    • Vaishali, you read my mind.. this morning when I woke up, I was thinking of this recipe and how it can be made egg less. In fact, I logged in to write my suggestions to make it egg less. I don’t know if you get jell-o instant pudding in India. You can use chocolate flavor. OR, you can make the filling skipping the egg and it will be fine. OR use a little bit of agar agar. Too many options for egg less filling.

  3. Nice delicious eggless recipe.

    Ongoing Event: MurariAnniversary-Giveaway-2012

  4. Very inviting pie…

  5. Wow that looks fantastic Usha…

  6. lovin it with this wonderful recipe

  7. That is drool worthy!

  8. I love the dish… its mouth watering…

  9. drooling…yum yum

  10. Wow that looks awesome glad you joined me…wonderful week of chocolate dishes!

  11. Usha, this looks drool worthy

  12. Seriously cant take my eyes from ur irresistible click,super tempting and terrific pie.

  13. Looks awesome and delicious…yummy..yummy..

  14. looks really yummy and rich!

  15. That looks delectable, Usha.

  16. delicious looking pie..thanks for linking with my event

  17. Delish and Delish!! Yum and yum!

  18. This looks delicious.Bookmarking this.

  19. The crust , filling and the frosting look so luscious and absolutely yummy!

  20. I’m ready for this pie now, can I have some please :)

  21. Looks fabulous with interesting filling!

  22. This looks so very delectable!

Leave a Reply